"When
I use a word," Humpty Dumpty said, in a rather scornful tone,
"it means just what I choose it to mean - neither more nor
less."
"The question is," said Alice, "whether you can make
words mean so many different things."
"The question is," said Humpty Dumpty, "which is to
be master - that's all."
(Lewis Carroll: Through the Looking Glass)
|
|
*The
national Service Framework for Mental Health: modernising mental
health services.
[Department of Health, 1998]
|
According
to the UK's Department of Health, ‘One adult in six suffers from one or other form of mental
illness.’*
Although
we may be tempted to regard mental illness as little
more than a
form of malingering or that the suffering it involves is not as real or intense as that
arising from physical illness, it is in fact no less real and no less distressing, if not more.
|
Meanings
|
Defining mental illness is difficult because, as Humpty Dumpty was trying to explain to Alice,
many words
do not convey the same meaning to everyone. 'Illness' and
'health, for example, are parts of a continuum; they can only be distinguished in
their more extreme forms. Less extreme, they 'shade into' each
other.
Mostly, 'illness' is used to describe the state in which people
themselves, and
perhaps also their families, friends,
associates or employers, judge them incapable of functioning as well
as they normally would or would like to; so the
difficulty of establishing the exact point at which wellness becomes illness
is sometimes resolved only by seeking a medical opinion.
|
|
Physical
illness |
Physical
illnesses are easier to determine than mental illnesses because they they are mostly characterised by the presence of pathogens or
lesions that are amenable to standard procedures.
Influenza, for example, results from a virus
exploiting a weakened immune system; malaria results from
infection by a mosquito-borne parasite and byssinosis (a lung
allergy) can be caused by dust in a cotton factory, and so on.
|
Organic &
functional mental
illness
|
The
term 'mental
illness' generally includes two distinct forms:
'organic' and 'functional'. Organic mental illness follows
brain impairment — such as the
dementias that result from Alzheimer's, Pick's,
Creutzfeldt-Jakob's and Huntingdon's diseases, acquired immune
deficiency syndrome (AIDS) and those that follow dependence on mood-altering substances.
Although called mental, these would more accurately be classified as physical, because the brain is a physical organ.
Mental illness not caused by brain impairment is called
functional because it results from malfunction of the person's
mind.
Although
cases of organic mental illness are rare by comparison with the
functional, many symptoms are common to both and both
therefore are sometimes referred to psychiatrists for attention.
Consequently, despite the absence of evidence, some people wrongly
assume that functional cases do originate from brain impairment.
|
A
misleading example |
Indeed,
electronic scanning of some brains of people diagnosed as suffering
from schizophrenia indicate abnormalities and researchers have
suggested that this indicates brain impairment as a cause and perhaps
a genetic disposition.
They have yet to find evidence, however, that the brains of everyone
so diagnosed are abnormal and, even if that evidence were
available, it
would not indicate whether the abnormality was the cause or
the effect of the illness.
The
dynamic brain patterns of people in love, for instance, are almost certainly
different from those of people who have recently experienced, say, sudden
bereavement. Both patterns are 'abnormal'. The
brain patterns serve our minds and master them only when the brain is
itself impaired.
|
|
Mind |
'Mind',
in fact,
is a
compact word that includes awareness, perceiving, thinking, believing, wondering,
remembering, calculating, analysing, judging, deciding, planning, learning,
knowing, understanding, sensing, fearing, hoping, wanting,
imagining and so on.
It is thus a group of mental activities; not a physical organ.
Consequently, the mind cannot be damaged or diseased in the same way as
the brain, although infection by drugs,
viruses and so on can damage the brain and thus also the mind.
|
Mind
and behaviour
'Social
and political assumptions sometimes lie at the heart of what
we regard as mental pathology ...',
Michael King, Glenn Smith
& Annie Bartle,
British Medical Journal, 21st February 2004
*
Reported in
The Times 12th April 2000; see also earlier editions of the American
Psychiatric Association's Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of
Mental Disorders. |
Patients
suffering from functional mental illness are likely to experience emotional
turmoil, irrational, jumbled or bizarre thoughts and to have difficulty making sense of what
they thought they
understood. Consequently, their behaviour may go awry
and perhaps be socially unacceptable.
In the USSR and more recently in
China, political dissidents were forced to accept psychiatric treatment because
their behaviour led their political masters to assume that their minds were
disordered.
More
astonishingly, 'psychopathic' behaviours, such as pyromania, kleptomania,
paedophilia and sadomasochism are not normally classed as mental
illnesses because no recognised medical
treatment for them exists!
|
|
Malingering
*Hamlet
Act V, scene ii |
Difficulty understanding the nature of functional mental illness
does indeed offer opportunities for malingering, either deliberate or
involuntary.
Some people in important social positions, for example, appear to have
avoided criminal prosecution because their psychiatrist
certified that they were suffering from mental illness.
Apparently, too, surgeons have been known to operate, despite their professional judgement,
because they were persuaded that the patient's mental
health would otherwise deteriorate.
Children
considered to be suffering from a recognised form of mental illness,
too, can easily mislead themselves or their carers to believe that their unacceptable behaviour is caused by
the illness and not by them. As Shakespeare wrote,
| If Hamlet from himself be ta'en away and,
when he's not himself, does wrong Laertes, Then Hamlet does it not; Hamlet denies it. Who does it
then? His madness: if 't be so, Hamlet is the faction that is wrong'd;
his madness is poor Hamlet's enemy.* |
Such
instances might, however, be more accurately described as 'conversion
hysteria' in which patients suffer genuine physical symptoms of illness but are
totally unaware of their underlying mental trauma.
|
|
Managing
functional mental illness |
Because
everyone's mind is different, no one can have exactly the same experience
of a particular functional
mental illness as anyone else and, for the same reason,
determining the exact causes of functional mental illness is likely to
be more complex than determining the causes of physical or organic illnesses.
|
The
biological approach |
Many people argue
that, because we are fundamentally biological machines, the best way of managing functional
mental illness is to modify the activity of our brains by chemical or mechanical
intervention, such as mood-altering drugs or
electro-convulsive therapy. The advantage of such
treatments is that they provide a relatively simple,
convenient and sometimes rapid,
relief of the symptoms.
|
Categories of functional mental illness
A more complete list of categories can be
found in the American Psychiatric Association's Diagnostic and
Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM IV), currently under review, and in
the World Health Organisation's International Classification of
Diseases.
|
Consequently,
people who seek medical help for a functional mental illness are
likely to be
advised that they are suffer from a categorised form of the
illness. These categories are arbitrary, or ‘conjectural’,
groups of symptoms, unrelated as would be the
case with physical illness, to well-established causes.
None the less, the categories
enable medical practicians to select particular forms of treatment and
reassure their patients that the condition is a medically recognised one.
Examples are:
agoraphobia,
attention deficit/hyperactivity, anorexia nervosa, bulimia nervosa,
chronic fatigue, clinical depression, irritable bowel, manic
depression, multiple personality, non-organic enuresis,
obsession-compulsion, paranoia, post-natal depression, post-traumatic
stress, schizophrenia.
|
|
Disadvantages
of the biological approach |
Although
a biological approach to organic mental illnesses is
appropriate (because they are essentially physical, not mental), the
same approach to functional mental illness is
problematical. In the absence of any evident lesion,
the chances of discovering direct causes are minimal. The fact that
the symptoms of functional mental illnesses are often relieved by such methods
does not indicate that the cause is primarily biological. Dispelling
a headache by absorbing an analgesic substance, for instance,
does not indicate that a
deficiency of the substance was the primary, or even a
contributory, cause of the headache!
Similarly, many people believe that the hormonal imbalance concomitant
with parturition is the main cause of post-natal depression.
If so, however, their theory does not
explain why so many women
give birth without becoming depressed.
Finally, some mood-altering drugs can have long-term adverse
effects on the brain, liver and lungs.
Electro-convulsive therapy is reputed to be even more drastic
and no one knows iwhether some of its side-effects are permanent.
|
The
holistic approach
|
‘Stress’,
a surfeit of perceptions, or 'information overload', is a
major factor leading to functional mental
illness. Mostly, we are able to cope without becoming so
ill that we need professional help, but our capacity for dealing with
the stress intrinsic to living is limited; an excess of entirely unexpected,
perhaps unprecedented
circumstances can easily overwhelm our minds. We become ‘unbalanced
and cannot ‘see the wood for the
trees’. We are not flawed or defective; simply
human.
Headaches, depression, anxiety, panic attacks, listlessness, shortness
of temper and nightmares may be warnings that we may need to withdraw
from the situation at least temporarily in order to determine what is
really troubling us and the best way of dealing with
it.
|
|
Stress |
The
main contributing stress factors are the often conflicting demands of
staying alive, avoiding or eliminating pain or distress and doing
whatever seems right against a backdrop of social
norms. When the detailed causes
of stress are investigated, perhaps helped by someone who
specialises in such work, they are nearly always found to be
rooted in difficulty – sometimes severe – coping with such
adversities as:
childhood abuse; emotional or material deprivation; puberty; marital
breakdown; unsatisfactory relationships; parenthood and the
eventual ‘empty nest’; bereavement; loss of financial or
social status; unemployment; arduous working conditions;
involvement in a serious accident; heavy or
prolonged bombardment; neighbourhood crime; violence; intrusive noise; complete isolation or abandonment.
Some of these events, particularly
the more traumatic, may result in personality changes.
Brain
impairment is not a cause of functional mental
illness, but it may sometimes be a consequence!
|
Musar
Haskei
|
Functional mental
illness is an existential condition that can be alleviated, but not
cured, by medical
treatment.
‘Life', as
Hai
Gaon wrote in the early
11th century, 'is a terrible disease, cured only by death!'
|
Links:
Suggested Reading:
Illusion
and Reality: The Meaning of Anxiety by David
Smail. J.M. Dent & Sons, London 1984.
Making Us Crazy: DSM,The Psychiatric Bible and the Creation of Mental Disorders by Herb Kutchins & Stuart A.
Kirk. The Free Press, New York 1997
'Recent advances in understanding mental illness and
psychotic experiences': a report by the British
Psychological Division of Clinical Psychology June 2000.
'The
Limits of Psychiatry' by Duncan Double British Medical Journal
2002; 32: 900-904
Post Traumatic Stress Disorder: Issues and Controversies ed. Gerald
M. Rosen. Wiley 2004
Violence
and Society: Making Sense of Madness and Badness by Elie Godsi.
PCCS Books 2004
Sick and Tired:
healing the illnesses doctors cannot cure by Nick Read. Weidenfeld &
Nicolson 2005
'The Limits of BIomedical Models of Distress' by Lucy
Johnstone (and)
'Critical Child Psychiatry' by Sami Timimi in Critical Psychiatry ed.
Duncan Double. Palgrave Macmillan 2006
Doctoring the Mind by Richard Bentall. Allen Lane 2009

|